Site content is copyright 1997-present Diane Richardson, Copying ANYTHING  from or direct linking to files on this site without written permission from Diane Richardson is prohibited

home buttonHome nextbuttonNext Page


If you find this information useful,

please consider donating by clicking Bonnie's face below, to keep the website online.
Thank you!


"Interested in Breeding Your Dog?" (my article from the late 90's)

Animal Rights vs Breeders

Suggested Reading

Interested In Breeding Your Dog?

This is an article I wrote back in the late 90's and has been reprinted in many magazines and websites

I fully appreciate the desire to breed purebred dogs. As a child I dreamed about raising dogs for a living. I thought why else would anyone spend several hundred dollars for an animal and not breed it to make their money back? Growing up on a working farm sure instills this "earn your keep" belief system into a child's head! After all , no farmer keeps livestock around that is not earning it's keep- either by working, producing a product or producing offspring.

However, something I had not known as a child was that dog breeders are looked at very differently than farmers. I found that dog breeders are actually divided into 2 basic categories:

1) High Risk- Backyard ,high volume or casual breeders. If breeders produce alot of puppies from parents who are housed and treated like livestock- they are also in this category and are known as puppy mills. This category is not highly thought of and humane societies, trainers and veterinarians are always warning people about avoiding this type of breeder

2) Reputable, ethical, good breeders

Now at this point I decided that I for sure did not want to be the first type of breeder, because being a person of pretty low self esteem I certainly did not want ANYONE saying anything bad about me or my dogs!

So I began my search for information about just what was involved in being a "good" breeder and just what that meant dollar wise. And let me tell you that the more I researched, the more I found that being a "good" breeder was going to smash every childhood image I had ever had!

First off being a "good" breeder means that your dogs get individual attention daily and are not just kept out in the kennel area like cattle in a barnyard. This "rule" seriously limits the number of dogs a "good" breeder can possibly own.

Next, I learned that in order to sell your dogs for a decent price you have to show or work your dogs in some activity on an official level and do well. Showing and competing is frustrating and expensive - even when you know what you are doing, let alone when you are a beginner! To do well you must have a good dog and practice-LOTS!

Buyers-now a days- are also more educated and are less willing to buy puppies whose parents do not have proper health clearences (hips X rayed, heart checked and certified at the very least). And some of these health clearances cannot be done until the dog is over 2 years old! All this pre-breeding certification and the waiting until the dog was over 2 years old was a new twist to me. Farmers rarely concern themselves with any health testing beyond "looks and acts fine" and is "all grown up now". Additionally and amazingly enough I also discovered that impressive, title filled pedigrees (documented family trees) matter a lot to most people, even if they can't decipher them! Gosh! people buying cattle, rabbits, pigs, chickens or everyday horses rarely ever ask about registration papers let alone pedigrees!

And even more unusual to me (compared to farm life) was the premise that to be a "good" breeder you are expected to "screen" buyers! If you sell pups to anybody who has the money you instantly fall into that dreaded high risk breeder category! You are fully expected to "screen" out the bad homes and only sell to the "good" homes. AND to further demonstrate your moral standings as a "good" breeder, you must have a written contract that makes health guarantees, assures that you will take back any dog that can no longer be kept by his owner and require buyers to take good care of the dog including spay or neuter of pups sold to pet homes. This is a whole lot of work that farmers never, ever have to do!

SO , OK- I'm educated now. Time to go shopping for a dog. A nice breeding quality puppy averages between $800 and $2500 Pretty steep but do-able. Alright so now buy a male and female and get started right? Wrong! I found that very rarely do "good" breeders breed their females to their own stud dogs.Usually the females are bred to other people's males that have competitive titles, fancy pedigrees and LOTS of health clearances. And no, the neighbors male just won't do. TOTALLY un farmlike!

Alright the female is now 2 years old, has her health clearences, has done well competively at something official so now it is stud dog shopping time. Stud fees average between $800 and $2500, wow! Then the male's owner wants the female to be tested for brucellosis (a sexually transmitted disease) and a negative worm check- more money.

But, ok all that money is now spent and the female will have a normal pregnancy and deliver the pups herself like a pig right? Well maybe, and maybe not. The pregnant female needs to be fed a really good diet and given proper exercise. Then she may deliver just fine. But maybe not. She might need a C section (which is expensive). Some females even die delivering pups! Some have no milk and some hate their puppies! WOW! I never thought about all that.

Then all the pups are born just fine and now we are all set to get ready to rake in the dollars, right? Nope, sorry. Firstly- some breeds require that their tails and/or dewclaws be removed by a veterinarian and that costs money.And unlike livestock buyers, puppy buyers expect an outgoing, healthy, well socialized puppy that has been in your home and not just out in the barn or kennel. This means that the puppies will need a lot of attention and exposure to people and noises. AND puppies are susceptible to more illness and require more vaccinations, etc than farm animals to stay healthy. Then there are the veterinarian issued health certificates required by many states to sell the 8 week old puppies (and no you cannot sell them before that age because they do not develop properly mentally if taken away from mom and family too young). PLUS all that puppy food (which makes mountains of poop that must be cleaned up several times a day) that is more expensive than grain especially since cheap, low quality dog food makes unhealthy pups!

Then there is advertising. Another BIG expense. You can't just throw an ad in the Market Bulletin. To be sure that all the pups are gone to their new "good" homes by 12 weeks of age, you have to start advertising before the puppies are even born! AND you have to be prepared for the fact that you MAY have to keep 1 or more pups longer if not enough "good" homes come along.

The biggest shock to my farm raised brain was the fact that rarely if ever does a "good" breeder make a profit! And often they actually lose money! You're probably wondering- like I was- why on earth would anyone go to all this time, heartbreak and expense if they aren't going to make money at it???

After breeding dogs since 1991 and after talking to MANY breeders both good and not so good, I have discovered that most "good" breeders breed for several reasons NONE of which include making money!:

1) They love the breed and enjoy competing or working with them and breed to produce another working or show dog and friend that is similar or better than it's parents

2) To continue a family line that has been painstakingly developed

3) To provide "good" homes with high quality, healthy pets and competition dogs

This journey from "dog raising for profit" mentality/childhood dream to"good" breeder reality took me 12 years and a lot of research. I am hoping that this article helps you- the reader- to educate yourself in a much shorter time span. Yes, being a "good" breeder is tough, heartbreaking, lots of work and not for everyone. And being a high risk/casual breeder does seem pretty easy, but in reality being a high risk breeder only hurts the breed you love and produces many puppies that later end up in humane societies unwanted and dead. Do you REALLY want "that" riding on your soul??

PLEASE, if you MUST breed then be a "good" responsible breeder- it is worth every hardship in the long run!

Animal Rights vs Breeders

The Animal Rights groups lump ALL breeders of animals into one evil category, one that needs to be destroyed.

Because of this there is a HUGE trend among animal breeders in general to claim you MUST support the rights of EVERYONE to breed even if they are high volume breeders,  commercial breeders, careless breeders, breeders who sell to brokers and pet shops and auctions because we are ALL breeders and the Animal Rights folks sees us as all the same. That If ALL breeders don't support the rights of all to breed no matter how they do it, that we will ALL lose that right.

I see that as a totally wrong headed train of thought.
The ethical and responsible breeder who:
breeds each litter with great thought put into the matches and not just breeding to produce a litter or to a "name brand" dog because his pups will sell well, even if he is not the best stud for the bitch.
Who does not breed more than 5 litters a year or stud their male to every bitch whose owner asks.
health test their dogs (or whatever species they breed-I'm just using dog since that is what I breed),
who breed dogs correct to the standard,
dogs who are sound in mind, body and health,
dogs who are capable of doing some sort of a job (be it obedience or whatever),
who care about the breed and stud book integrity,
who screen their buyers,
who take back their puppies whenever and why ever at any point in their lives
and who are active in their dogs lives from day one til death.
THOSE are the breeders who should be supported!

 If ALL breeders in this category would band together and eliminate all the other types of breeders it would be for the good of all dogs everywhere.

I care not at all that the market demand is greater than GOOD breeders can ever produce enough puppies for. Dogs are not tomatos and if buyers cannot wait for a good, healthy, sound, ethically and responsibly bred dog then they honestly don't need one.

NO Breeder should feel pressured to breed to fill demand.

It is not all breeders or no breeders, it is the defenders of canine, equine, etc heritage and careful ethical breeding against those who simply see the animals as income and care not about the breed heritage, the breed health and soundness or the buyers.

Who cares what the Animal Right people think?
There ARE good, wonderful animal breeders AND shelters AND Rescue groups.
There are also horrible animal breeders, shelters and rescue groups.
The good and ethical examples MUST stand together for the good of the animals and help eliminate any examples that do NOT have the good of the animals, their heritage and the people who love them at heart!
Watch for upcoming legislation in your states and write in SUPPORT of bills that will encourage accountability and write against those bills that would restrict those doing good or lump them in with those who are not

The above is not "my opinion" nor "what I can handle"
(for me personally 2-3 a year is my limit because of how much I train and socialize them before they leave at 10 weeks)

It is what is good for a breed first and foremost, followed by what is good for the puppies produced and the buyers of those pups.

There is a very HIGH PROFILE example of this in another breed, they did just that (10+ litters a year) and changed the ENTIRE breed in the US.

Anyone producing that many litters a year WILL have a HUGE impact on their breed and it is usually not good for ANY breed in the long run.

I have NO USE for people who think we need to protect those who are not good for a breed to keep "the rest of us safe"


Successful Dog Breeding: The Complete Handbook of Canine Midwifery (Howell reference books)

Canine Reproduction: The Breeder's Guide

Canine Reproduction And Whelping: A Dog Breeder's Guide

Puppy Intensive Care: A Breeder's Guide to Care of Newborn Puppies

Advanced Canine Reproduction and Puppy Care: The Seminar



Darla Button     Our Rottweilers
Past and present

Darla Button     Rottweiler Info
about; JLPP; SAS; Embark; choosing a breeder;
long coat; wire coat; red coat;purr/grumble;

Darla ButtonRaising Rottweilers
Darla ButtonBearded Rottweilers
Beards, Wire coat, Furnishing test

Darla Button       Red Rottweilers
Color history, red and other "off" colors"

Darla ButtonJLPP, LEMP, NAD
Inherited neurological diseases

Darla ButtonSub Aortic Stenosis
SAS in Rottweilers

Darla Button         Hip Dysplasia

Darla Button

Transitional Cell Carcinoma
our TCC journey with Angelica

Darla Button

Autoimmune Hemolytic Anemia
Our AIHA journey with Bonnie

Darla Button       Titer Project

our multi breed project tracking Distemper/ Parvovirus titers in our dogs

Darla Button   Rottweiler Art


Kennel Story
History, Health stats,
Insurance, etc

Breeding Info
Interest in breeding dogs?
Written by Diane Richardson
Clicker Info
How to use clicker training method
Boarding Tips
Choosing a boarding kennel
Our breedings past and future
Cortez Button
Our Shiba Inu

Past dogs
bella button
Bella's Page
dog art store


dogs by diane banner



Frontier Rottweilers
Diane Richardson
P.O. 160
Georges Mills, NH 03751
(603) 558-9042

click the howling puppy to email us!


Send questions and comments to: Diane Richardson
Last updated 6/21/23
Copyright 2023 Diane Richardson, All Rights Reserved